Decoding Banishment Decree: MTG Power and Toughness Ratios

In TCG ·

Banishment Decree artwork from Mirrodin Besieged, white instant

Image courtesy of Scryfall.com

Understanding Power, Value, and the Language of Ratios

In Magic: The Gathering, power and toughness are not the only axes by which we measure a card’s true weight. The real engine behind many deciding moves is the formula of value per mana—the ratio that tells you how much leverage a spell bags for its price. When you pull a card like Banishment Decree into a game, you’re not watching a creature’s P/T ratio swing the game; you’re watching a carefully crafted tempo play bend the flow of turns, reshaping what the next draw will reveal. 🧙‍♂️🔥

Banishment Decree is a white instant from Mirrodin Besieged, with a mana cost of {3}{W}{W} and common rarity. The effect is clean, precise, and surprisingly versatile: “Put target artifact, creature, or enchantment on top of its owner’s library.” That single line packs a multi-layered punch. On the surface, you deny an immediate threat by forcing the opponent to draw their next card later, but the real leverage comes from how it interacts with a dozen micro-choices during a game: which card is likely to be drawn next, do you need to shuffle, and what happens if your opponent topdecks a game-critical spell in their own tempo plan? The power-to-cost ratio here is about tempo preservation and disruption more than it is about brute force. ⚔️

To understand the ratio in practical terms, compare this spell to the classic creature-centric powerhouses you might see on a punchy gold-card or on a big bomb. A five-mana instantaneous effect that reorders your opponent’s reach is the kind of value that can win a race or stall a combo loop without committing a bulky body to the battlefield. In other words, Banishment Decree trades a chunk of raw damage potential for slow-burn control—the sort of exchange white players love when they’re aiming to stabilize and then accelerate toward a victory path. The “5 mana for a delayed, but decisive, effect” ratio is where the card earns its keep in a modern control shell or in a prison-style white archetype. 🧠

Speaking of archetypes, this card’s design leans into white’s historically reliable toolkit: tempo control, artifact/enchantment hate, and a knack for turning the opponent’s plan into a story about their next draw. It’s also a window into the lore of Mirrodin Besieged—the phyrexian watermark on this card hints at a world where corruption and order clash on the battlefield. The flavor text—"Unworthy of consecration." — Axsh, lesser cenobite—gives you a sense of the dark underbelly that bleeds into white’s more disciplined integrity. The artwork by James Ryman captures that icy, surgical precision—just the kind of moment you want when you’re debating whether to cast this spell now or in response to a looming threat. 🧙‍♂️🎨

For players building decks around this kind of interaction, a useful rule of thumb is to value spells that bend the opponent’s next few turns more than those that simply remove a threat. Banishment Decree fits neatly into midrange and control shells that want to slow down a game long enough to snap up a crucial follow-up, or to protect a single piece of your own plan while you set up a more permanent reply. Its flexibility—targeting artifacts, creatures, or enchantments—keeps it relevant across a range of matchups, especially against decks that rely on powerful threats or key mana acceleration. And in formats where drawing the wrong card at the wrong time can mean the difference between a win and a loss, this instant’s ability to “mis-time” an opponent’s draw can be the difference-maker. 🧲

In the end, decoding this card’s power-to-toughness analogy comes down to recognizing the value of timing and context. A creature’s P/T ratio is a constant baseline you can measure in every combat. Banishment Decree, by contrast, is a clock: it tells you when to strike to push the game toward your preferred tempo. That’s the essence of MTG strategy—finding the moments when a well-timed play creates more leverage than a raw stat line ever could. And if you’re kicking back with a neon phone case that holds your cards safely—shiny, protective, and ready for the table—remember that the best cards are the ones that help you stay focused during the long game. 🧙‍♀️🎲

Neon Phone Case with Card Holder MagSafe-Compatible Glossy Matte

More from our network

← Back to All Posts