Image courtesy of Scryfall.com
Dream Eater’s opening hand: what to keep and what to ship
If you’re piloting this Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander mythic, you’re playing a blue control tempo game with a spicy surveil engine that can tilt the battlefield with a well-timed bounce to boot. Dream Eater arrives with a big demand: you’re looking to cash in its enter-the-battlefield surveil trigger and the bounce upside on an opponent’s nonland permanent. It’s a card that rewards you for having a plan, not just a big spell in your hand. 🧙🔥💎 When you mulligan, the question isn’t just “do I have enough mana?” It’s “do I have a coherent plan to get to the surveil-and-bounce line while keeping pressure on opponents?” In London Mulligan terms, you’ll draw seven, decide what to send back, and keep with a slate of cards that helps you reach your blue-dominant, draw-rich, control-leaning axis. In practice, you’re aiming for a start that can develop blue mana sources quickly, plus something that fuels card advantage or surveil on turn one or two. The goal is to reach turn four or five with Dream Eater online, ready to surveil and disrupt in the same breath. 🧭 The card lives in a color identity that loves to see card draw, cantrips, or minimal mana acceleration as you approach your six-mana investment. So if your opening hand is short on blue sources, short on card draw, or lacks a guardrail against early aggression, you should consider sending it back. Conversely, a hand that pairs two or more blue-producing lands (or mana rocks), Dream Eater, and even a simple cantrip or surveil enabler creates a backbone you can develop into a nimble, late-game threat. The daydream of surging into a big flying threat with Flash is real, and that threatening tempo is exactly what keeps opponents honest. ⚔️Key mulligan heuristics for blue control tempo in this deck
- Prioritize blue mana availability early. Dream Eater’s mana cost is 4UU, so you want at least two reliable blue sources by turn two or three, with an eye toward acceleration if possible. If you don’t have a believable path to cast it by midgame, you’ll want to cycle for better options. 🧙 - Value surveil triggers matter. Any hand that includes a surveil enabler (or even a cantrip that replaces itself) gives you insurance to sculpt your next draws and set up the important enter-the-battlefield line. Surveil 4 is not just a flavor text; it’s a planning tool that lets you assemble the exact mix of cards you need on the top of your library, while also preparing the bounce target for later. 🎯 - The bounce condition is your tempo leash. Dream Eater can bounce a nonland permanent an opponent controls when you surveil. Keeping a sense of the table’s threats helps you decide when to keep or ship a hand. If your opponents have a critical nonland threat you could answer with the surveil-bounce line, that improves your odds of sticking around. Remember, you can bounce their stuff, not yours—so don’t keep a hand that’s too eager to flash in for a bounce without a plan. 🪄 - Flexibility beats raw power. In Commander, you’ll often face wide boards and many different threats. A hand with two blue sources plus a draw spell or utility spell gives you flexibility to react, whereas a hand with less interaction may stall you out of the negotiation table. Balance tempo with protection. 🎲 - Don’t panic if you see a pure topdeck hand. Dream Eater’s strength is in its ability to sculpt your draws and punish over-commitment, but you still need the right setup to survive early turns. If your opening hand includes an early cantrip or a blue mana accelerant, you’re still in a good position to lean into a late-game play. 🎨Sample opening hands: keep or ship scenarios
- Keep scenario A: You open with two blue sources (or blue rocks), Dream Eater, a cantrip, and a small spell that can draw you deeper. This is a clean path toward turn four or five where you can cast Dream Eater, surveil four, and potentially bounce a key nonland permanent from an opponent. It’s the archetype of “slow, steady, and surgical.” 🧩 - Keep scenario B: A hand with one early mana acceleration (like a mana rock that produces blue) plus a surveil-enabling spell, and a backup plan (perhaps another counterspell or removal). The bounce line is still viable, and you’ve got the engine to refill your grip after the initial play, smoothing your way into the late game. 💡 - Ship scenario: Three or more cards that are strictly “dead by turn four” in this deck’s rhythm, or a hand entirely lacking blue mana sources or a surveil engine. In this case, you’re better off cycling to find a more coherent start rather than compounding mulligans and delaying your dream of surveillance-driven control. Some players may hold more aggressively in multiplayer formats, but a shoulder-season mulligan toward a steadier mana/interrupt plan is prudent. 🧊Multi-player dynamics and the Dream Eater tempo
In EDH, you’re not just trying to cast Dream Eater; you’re trying to shape the battlefield. The surveil on entry makes it a tempo engine that draws you toward your core survivability while you prepare to disrupt opponents’ boards. You can use the surveil to set up draws that find additional control pieces, or to bury a critical card in your library to the bottom for later access. The bounce ability shines against a single, heavy win condition or a troublesome nonland permanent like an overbearing EtB engine in your pod. It’s not just removal; it’s a diplomatic tool that can swing the table’s momentum in your favor. 🗺️ If you’re curious about how this card slots into broader blue commander strategies, you’ll often see Dream Eater in decks that want to angle for late-game inevitability while staying light on tapped-out turns. The flavor of Duskmourn—where cunning and shadowy power intersect—pairs perfectly with a control plan that relies on precise information and exact timing. The mind-bending Surveil mechanic makes you the player with the chessboard in hand, and that kind of mental gymnastics is exactly what many of us love about this corner of the multiverse. 🎭For those who enjoy blending style with function, a little practical chic can go a long way. While you’re plotting your next move, consider maxing out your setup with gear that keeps your deck tidy and your life total unthreatened. And if you’re looking for a stylish way to carry your deck and accessories between events, this product might be the perfect sidekick for your table—compact, sturdy, and ready to roll when you are. Phone Case with Card Holder — Impact Resistant Polycarbonate keeps your essentials safe while you plan your next big play. 🧙♂️💼
“A good mulligan is a plan with a plan B, C, and D—preferably all blue.”