Image courtesy of Scryfall.com
Un-set Visions and Visual Constraints in Saruman's Trickery
If you love the delightful tension between parody and precision in Magic: The Gathering, Saruman's Trickery is a perfect case study. Released as part of The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth, this blue instant brings two very different promises to the party: a counterspell and a small but quirky path to board presence through an Amass Orcs 1 trigger. The card codifies design constraints that undercut grandiose “Un-set” bravado while leaning into the playful spirit of parody that fans adore. 🧙🔥💎
Designers walk a careful line when they bend visuals into humor. In a traditional set, clarity and legibility are non-negotiable: mana costs must read cleanly, reminder text must be scannable, and the rules text needs to be immediately actionable. In Un-set style—where humor and wink-winks are the currency—the constraints relax just enough to let jokes land without breaking the game's mechanical predictability. This balance is most evident in a card like Saruman's Trickery, which pairs a classic blue counterspell arc with a cheeky Army-formation mechanic. The result is a look that feels mischievous, but never confusing. 🎨
From a visual-design perspective, the card leans into blue’s iconic aesthetic: crisp serif font for the rules text, a cool cyan hue for the mana cost, and a composition that communicates “counter” at a glance. The mana cost, {1}{U}{U}, is balanced to feel fair in tempo while signaling that this spell is a precise tool rather than a fireworks display. The light, high-contrast iconography ensures players can read it under table lamps and on crowded virtual tables alike. In the Un-set spirit, that readability becomes the backbone of humor—the joke lands when you can immediately see the counterspell intent and the quirky Amass Orcs payoff. ⚔️🎨
“I gave you the chance of aiding me willingly.” — Saruman
The flavor text anchors the joke in lore rather than slapstick: Saruman’s duplicity shines through even as the card presents an unexpectedly silly board state. This is where the visual constraint philosophy nods to the source material—LOTR—while staying tethered to MTG’s core principles. The artwork by Yongjae Choi adds a layer of characterful menace, which helps the card feel like a legitimate strategic option rather than a mere gag. The color palette and illustration style strike a middle ground between cinematic fantasy and tabletop clarity, a nod to fans who crave immersion without sacrificing playability. 🧙🔥
What makes the “Un-set” mindset feel tangible here?
- Humor anchored to mechanics: The Amass Orcs 1 clause is a playful nod to a popular tribal mechanic, but it’s anchored to the canonical counterspell idea. The humor isn’t in running an army that defies rules; it’s in the clever pairing of countering an opponent’s spell with the surprise of an Orc Army token showing up when you need a board presence.
- Typography and layout as punchline: Un-set visuals often rely on typography cues and layout jokes. In this card, the layout remains clean, but the concept invites a wink—blue’s elegance paired with a cheeky token payoff—without turning the mechanics into a visual gag that could confuse new players.
- Iconography that travels well: The blue mana symbols and the Amass token indicator are instantly recognizable, which matters when the humor may be more subtle. The ability to parse the card quickly while catching the joke is a hallmark of successful design under constraint. 🧲
- Flavor that supports, not overshadows: The line from Saruman grounds the wink in character, so the parody never tilts into background noise. Clear flavor helps players appreciate the joke while staying focused on how to play the card effectively. 🎲
Mechanics and the palette of playability
In practice, Saruman's Trickery offers a compact, three-mana package that blue decks often crave: tempo via countering a spell, plus incremental value via Amass Orcs. Amass is a keyword that creates an Army creature with a +1/+1 counter when you would otherwise gain it from an Amass trigger, and for a card like this, the synergy is delightfully oddball. The token is a creature type (Orc Army), which means it can be buffed, blocked, or used as a synergy target with other tribal or zombie-ish themes that love to lean into unexpected token armies. That blend—counter magic plus a tiny army—feels like a playful, but plausible, blue strategy in a LOTR-flavored universe. 🧙♂️⚔️
From a collector's perspective, the card's rarity is uncommon, which pairs nicely with the cross-promotion vibe of Universes Beyond sets. The card exists in both nonfoil and foil finishes, with modest market prices that reflect its niche appeal and limited print window. For players who enjoy brewing quirky combos or delight in LOTr references, Saruman's Trickery sits at a sweet spot—playable in Modern and Legacy alike, with a connection to EDH/Commander flavor through its late-game potential and unique interaction with Orc Army tokens. The set name, The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth, signals that this card isn’t just a one-off joke; it’s a deliberate cultural bridge that invites nostalgia and new play styles at the same table. 🧙🔥💎
Beyond the card’s immediate play value, the visual constraints of Un-set-inspired design teach us how to balance humor with clarity. The designers clearly prioritized legibility, even while injecting a narrative wink. The result is a card that feels both familiar and fresh—an important lesson for any crafting exercise, whether you’re building a theme deck, a fan-made homage, or a modern reinterpretation of a classic character. The art direction, typography, and iconography all serve the joke without tripping over the rules text, a delicate dance that true MTG fans recognize and celebrate. 🎨🧩
As you ponder the next addition to your desk setup, consider how a well-timed card can spark conversations while you optimize your counterspell tempo. And speaking of desk setup, if you’re looking to keep your workspace as sharp as your plays, this Non-Slip Gaming Mouse Pad is a stylish companion that complements late-night drafting sessions and tournament grind alike. It’s the kind of practical nerdy accessory that makes you smile whenever you slam a critter into play or counter a naysayer with style. ⌨️🎲